Talk:Citation

Suggestions:
"During the archiving and review process or when a moratorium is set on the data, for example due to the publication status of a connected manuscript, the data is kept in the status "in review". When the next sentence then states that it is "already findable and visible in PANGAEA", the reader might get confused. "During the archiving and review process or when a moratorium is set on the data, for example due to the publication status of a connected manuscript, the data is kept in the status ''"in review". Datasets "in review" are usually only accessible for the contributing authors after logging in to PANGAEA. However, the metadata, including authors, title, references and parameters are already findable and visible in PANGAEA. It is important to note that datasets "in review" might be modified or even deleted during the review process."--Judith s weber (talk) 2020-11-10T12:49:38 (UTC) --Judith s weber (talk) 2020-11-05T11:13:23 (UTC)
 * Maybe it should be mentioned whether a dataset "in review" is already published or only accessible internally. Include information in this sentence: "A dataset "in review" might be modified or even deleted during the review process."
 * I have added edited "A dataset "in review", although already findable and visible in PANGAEA, might be modified or even deleted during the review process.". In addition, I linked to status and password pages for explaining those issues. How about that? --Pittauer (talk) 2020-11-09T14:29:33 (UTC)
 * I would split it a little bit. It is a little tricky because in the first sentence it is stated that:
 * In the part "Publication of data in PANGAEA" we could skip the Scetch, it don't think it's useful.
 * Agreed, I will remove it--Judith s weber (talk) 2020-11-05T11:13:23 (UTC)
 * We can also add a text related to "citability" of datasets "in review" (see figure). The text in the box: This dataset is work in review, so PANGAEA did not yet assign and register a DOI name. Therefore, PANGAEA cannot guarantee persistence of the link provided here. The dataset may be modified or deleted at any time! Once the dataset has been published and has a minted DOI name, the following link will work: https://doi.org/10.1594/PANGAEA.XXXXX --Pittauer (talk) 2020-10-30T07:41:59 (UTC)
 * Good suggestion, I added a section in review
 * Should we call the Authors Authors? Now there is "Creator", unless there is a special reason for that, I'd go with "Author". --Pittauer (talk) 2020-10-30T07:45:01 (UTC)
 * Ah, is it what it's called at DataCite? --Pittauer (talk) 2020-10-30T07:46:28 (UTC)
 * Yes, data cite calls it creator! therefore I would keep it like that --Judith s weber (talk) 2020-11-05T11:13:23 (UTC)
 * It would be also important to add a suggestion where in the paper the dataset can be cited (dataset can be referred to anywhere in paper paper, e.g. in methods, results, ...). Also most of the journals have data availability section in the manuscript template
 * Add something like: Manuscript's Data availability statement example: "Data for this study were published open access (Authors, YYYY)." followed by a data set full citation in the List of references.
 * Done, see subchapter --Judith s weber (talk) 2020-11-05T11:31:39 (UTC)
 * Also mention that : In PANGAEA web interface, each published data set contains buttons in the header to copy citations or export the citations in the preferred format. --Pittauer (talk) 2020-10-30T11:35:57 (UTC)
 * done--Judith s weber (talk) 2020-11-05T11:23:17 (UTC)